The Stealth BriefHiring Economics

Korean SMEs back long tenure for foreign workers as productivity lags

5 min readStealth Agents Editorial1 sources cited
Korean SMEs back long tenure for foreign workers as productivity lags
Image: Stealth Agents (AI-generated illustration)

The news

A survey by the Korea Federation of Small and Medium Business (KFSB) of 1,204 small and medium-sized companies that employ foreign workers found that 92.1% said it is appropriate for E-9 visa workers to stay at their first workplace for more than three years after entry, Maeil Business Newspaper reported. That breaks down as 70.3% choosing "more than three years" and 21.8% choosing "three years or more."

The same survey found that 54.8% of respondents now assign foreign workers to higher-skilled jobs based on years of service, up from 48.2% the prior year. Expectations of worker proficiency are rising even as the underlying numbers stay modest.

On productivity, KFSB asked firms to rate foreign workers against domestic workers at the same conditions set to 100%. Foreign workers came in at 41.1% in the first three months and 68.1% at under one year. Respondents put the appropriate probation period at 4.3 months on average for a new hire to understand the work and adjust to company life.

Cost is the other half of the picture. Average monthly labor cost per foreign worker was 2.656 million won, split into 2.181 million won in salary, 427,000 won in overtime and 47,000 won in incidental expenses. Including accommodation and lodging of 426,000 won, the total reaches 3.082 million won, above 3 million won and up from roughly 2.928 million won in 2025.

Asked why they hire foreign workers, 83.6% cited a lack of available Korean workers. Only 4.5% cited labor cost reduction, down sharply from 13.4% a year earlier.

On the government's planned "Roadmap for Integrated Support for Foreign Personnel," employers were asked what would happen if workers could freely change workplaces after one to two years. The top expected difficulty was lost productivity and quality from turnover of skilled workers at 94.7%, followed by higher hiring and training costs for replacements at 75.2%. Those figures combine first through third rankings cited by owners.

On the current employment permit system, 56.8% said the most needed change is incentives for workers who have not changed workplaces for four years and 10 months. Next came sanctions for workers who leave without cause at 56%, then a wage system that accounts for foreign worker productivity at 43.8%.

Under the E-9 visa, workers can stay up to four years and 10 months without a separate visa renewal by extending one year and 10 months through re-employment permission after three years of employment.

Yang Ok-seok, head of KFSB's Human Resources Policy Division, said the survey confirmed that companies hire foreign workers to cope with difficulty finding Korean workers, not to cut labor costs, but that productivity is low and employment costs are heavy in the early stage. He said the federation hopes the permit system operates stably so workers can build skills and reach domestic-level productivity after entry.

Why it matters

This is a Korean survey, and we are not stretching it to cover US hiring. Read it as a case study in what happens when a labor shortage gets filled by workers who need a runway.

The pattern is familiar to any US operator running a thin team. You hire because you cannot fill the seat locally. The new person is not productive on day one. You carry wages, overtime and often housing or relocation before you see a return. Then, once you have trained them, the rules change and you risk losing exactly the people you invested in.

Two numbers deserve attention. The 4.3-month average probation period is a useful benchmark for how long employers think adaptation actually takes, not how long a job posting says it takes. And the 94.7% figure on turnover of skilled workers shows that retention policy, not recruiting policy, is where employers feel the most exposure.

The cost line is the one US small businesses should copy into their own models. A fully loaded monthly figure that includes housing is the only number that matters when you decide whether a hire pencils out.

What to do about it

  • Model fully loaded cost, not salary. KFSB's 3.082 million won figure includes 426,000 won in accommodation. Add housing, equipment, training time and supervision to every offer before you approve it.
  • Set a real ramp target. If new workers reach roughly 41% of experienced output in the first three months and 68% within a year, budget for that curve. Do not staff a client commitment on month-one output.
  • Write the retention plan before the offer. Decide what keeps a trained worker past year two: pay progression, schedule, a defined path. Employers in this survey named skilled-worker turnover as their top risk from looser rules.
  • Separate the shortage reason from the cost reason. 83.6% of these firms hire because they cannot find local workers; 4.5% cite cost. If cost is your real reason, say so and build the case on output per dollar, not on scarcity.
  • Use a structured 90-day review. Check output against the ramp target at 30, 60 and 90 days. If a hire is behind, fix the training or the role before you add headcount.

The Stealth take

The interesting finding here is not that 92.1% of employers want workers to stay. It is that they want them to stay while admitting the first year produces roughly two-thirds of a domestic worker's output. Employers are not confused about the tradeoff. They are choosing a long ramp because the alternative is an empty seat.

That tradeoff only works if the employer controls the ramp. Turnover of trained workers was the top concern at 94.7%, and the fix employers asked for was incentives for staying, not easier movement. Any staffing model that depends on workers who take months to get productive has to treat retention as an operating function, not an HR formality.

For US small and mid-sized firms, the practical lesson is to stop treating a hire as a fixed cost and start treating it as a curve. Know the loaded monthly number, know the month-three and month-twelve output targets, and know what keeps the person past year two. Firms that do this can staff through a tight market. Firms that do not will keep paying full cost for partial output and calling it a labor shortage.

We work with businesses building remote teams, and the same discipline applies: define the role, set the ramp, measure at 90 days, and plan retention before day one.

Sources